Supper Club Redux: Another Great Dinner at Hamilton’s Kitchen

Written By Scott Joseph On November 2, 2016

HamiltonSC table

We had our second Supper Club at Hamilton’s Kitchen at the Alfond Inn recently but the first one under the new chef, Jason Klingensmith. It was a chance for us to check out his cooking style, and he impressed us all.

We began the evening with a reception on the hotel’s courtyard patio enjoying some passed hors d’oeuvres and some wine. The weather was absolutely gorgeous so we were all a little disappointed when the staff invited us to go inside. But then we discovered that the doors of our private dining room had been flung open so we were able to enjoy the night air.

HamiltonSC reception

HamiltonSC klingensmith

We started the dinner with a King Crab Strudel with Meyer lemon and caviar butter. I tucked right into it and finished it so quickly that I forgot to take a photo. (Trust me, it was gorgeous.)

The strudel was paired with a 2012 Wirshing Silvaner Kabinett Trocken Iphofer Kronsberg, and if you think the name is a mouthful you should have tasted it!

Southeast 9 23 Bosch

HamiltonSC octopus

The next course featured Hours-long Octopus, so named because Klingensmith sous-vided the octopus before a final grilling. We’re seeing more of this type of preparation for octopus and I like it. It allows the buttery fatty layer of the tentacle to remain while still getting a nice char at the end. Here it was serve with bits of chorizo, an apt accompaniment for the Spanish octopus, and a broth flavored with truffles and parmesan.

Although the octopus was from Spain, the wine was from Italy, a 2014 Argiolas Vermentino di Sardegna. It had light notes of stone fruits and a touch of honey on the palate.

HamiltonSC pork belly

The Maple Glazed Pork Belly was served with a sweet potato pavé, French for cobblestone or paver, if you will, but much more toothsome with its multiple layers. The pork belly was wonderfully fatty but firm.

HamiltonSC inman

The dish went well with the deliciously fruity 2013 Inman Family Pinot Noir from the Russian River Valley.

HamiltonSC intermezzo

An intermezzo of Compressed Melon and Mint Granita, sprinkled with Black Sea Salt, helped clear our palates for the next course.

HamiltonSC lamb

Which was a Pistachio Crusted Lamb Chop, with butternut squash and tomato syrup. The double chop was cooked perfectly and was oh so tender.

HamiltonSC nebbiolo

I would have been perfectly happy to continue with the pinot noir for this course, but we were offered the 2012 Grimaldi Langhe Nebbiolo from Piemonte. And I have to admit, the black cherries and smooth tannins were perfect with the meat.

HamiltonSC pudding

We finished with now-famous Hamilton’s Kitchen Macallan 12-Year Butterscotch Pudding served with a chip of sea-salted toffee.

A great ending to a wonderful meal.

Our next Supper Club will be announced soon. As always, recipients of my e-letter get first chance at tickets. Out Hamilton’s Kitchen dinner sold out, so if you’d like to be included in the next one, make sure you’re on the list by clicking here.

We hope you find our reviews and news articles useful and entertaining. It has always been our goal to assist you in making informed decisions when spending your dining dollars. If we’ve helped you in any way, please consider making a contribution to help us continue our journalism. Thank you.

Scott's Newsletter