By Cuisine

Listings by cuisine specialty
What are you hungry for?

Read More

By Location

Where do you want to eat?
Restaurant listings for every city and neighborhood.

Read More

Foodster Awards

The best in Central Florida dining
Celebrating culinary excellence among Central Florida’s Independent restaurants.  

Read More

By Features

Looking for outdoor dining, Sunday brunch, a place for a banquet or somewhere quiet?

Read More
<div id="fb-root"></div>
<script async defer crossorigin="anonymous" src="https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js#xfbml=1&version=v17.0&appId=1360880647827568&autoLogAppEvents=1" nonce="nOICdQjC"></script>

Dinner Party Redux: A Last Supper Club at Dubsdread

Written By Scott Joseph On July 25, 2024

Supper Club is now adjourned.

Supper Club, more recently known as Dinner Party, was our occasional wine dinner event that started in 2011 with a gathering at the Citrus Club in Downtown Orlando and ended Wednesday evening in the Florida Room at Dubsdread, next door to the Tap Room at Dubsdread.

In between we had events at some of finest restaurants in Central Florida – and beyond, including an international Supper Club in Dublin, Ireland. And during the pandemic, we met virtually, with a Zoomed dinner featuring food and cocktails from Soco Thornton Park that was picked up or delivered to participants.

In bringing this aspect of Scott Joseph’s Orlando Restaurant Guide to a close, I strategically chose Dubsdread for one specific reason. When I started the website sixteen years ago, Tap Room at Dubsdread was the first one to sign on as a sponsor, and it has stayed with me the whole way. And as you may know, the rules for advertising on this site stipulate that only those restaurants that meet the standards for good food and service may do so.

Tap Room at Dubsdread certainly has met those qualifications and has maintained its high quality. We all know its award-winning burger and its great steaks and seafood. But the culinary team took our Dinner Party guests to a new level.

We started with an open bar reception in the vast banquet room as attendees found seats at the three long, white tableclothed tables set up for us. 

From left: Luis Perez, Amanda Nicholson, Jose Bofill and Trey Malonson.

Executive banquet chef Jose Bofill and sous chefs Amanda Nicholson and Luis Perez ran us through the menu, and Trey Malonson, a certified sommelier for Breakthru Beverage Florida, discussed the pairings. The wines were selected by Tap Room general manager Kelly Bofill. 

And could there have been a better wine selection than Taittinger Champagne to go with the amuse bouche of Spanish octopus and scallop crudo? (That’s a rhetorical question.) The dish, created by Nicholson, had blood orange segments with citrus oil and a fried rice paper crisp. 

Oysters Rockefeller was the appetizer, three plump mollusks in each serving (“That’s an entree,” someone nearby exclaimed), topped with a luscious mix of fresh spinach and cheese. More than a few people told me it was the best Rockefeller they’d had. They were even better with the Stag’s Leap chardonnay that accompanied.

The first of our two entrees was Harissa Marinated Lamb Lollipops. The frenched chops were stacked over an orzo pilaf that had caramelized apples and radicchio. A lovely  mint demi glace that was pooled on the plate was a nice counterpoint to the spice of the harissa. A cabernet Sauvignon from Penfolds with notes of chocolate and cedar stood up nicely to the characteristic gaminess of the lamb.

Duck breast from Maple Leaf Farms, cured in Illy Coffee, came next. The medallions of meat had a beautiful red center and crisped skin. It was served with sweet potato puree with swiss chard and a red wine reduction sauce. A plump Bordeaux cherry added a familiar taste. Dame de Gaffelière Saint-Émilion Grand Cru was the elegant pairing. Made mostly with merlot, the wine had a velvety texture and strong black fruit notes.

Dessert was a perfectly executed creme brûlée – a creamy custard topped with crackable sugar – made even better with white chocolate lavender. Even the dessert got its own wine, Ca Montebello Moscato. “We started with bubbles and we end with bubbles,” as Malonson put it.

Throughout the evening we were expertly served by the well-trained Dubsdread staff, who moved with perfect precision. We were dining officially under the auspices of Events by Dubsdread, the catering division, so they knew how to handle our sold-out dinner of more than 50 people.

It was a fitting finale.

We hope you find our reviews and news articles useful and entertaining. It has always been our goal to assist you in making informed decisions when spending your dining dollars. If we’ve helped you in any way, please consider making a contribution to help us continue our journalism. Thank you.

<?php comments_template() ?>
<div class="fb-comments" data-href="<?php the_permalink() ?>" data-width="100%" data-numposts="5"></div>
Scott's Newsletter